How do you choose a home health billing company? Pick one that does Medicare home health billing every day, puts its scope and fee calculation in writing, checks each claim before it goes out, shows you what needs attention, signs a business associate agreement before seeing patient data, and has a clear exit process. Compare every company on the same ten questions.
Use this guide in one sitting. Ask each company the ten questions, write down the answers, and fill in the comparison table near the end. It is general education, not legal advice.
1. Are you taking over billing, or selling a tool?
Ask for a list of the work included in the agreement. Does the company prepare and submit claims, follow responses, and track payments? Is it reviewing work that your existing biller will still perform? Or are you buying software your own team must operate?
These are different arrangements. Name who owns each step, including follow-up when something needs attention. If two companies are involved, ask which one answers your staff's questions.
2. How is the fee calculated, and when is it due?
Ask for a written example showing the charge and its calculation. If the fee is a percentage, establish what amount the percentage applies to: what Medicare allowed, what it actually paid, or something else. Ask about setup charges, minimum charges, work on older unpaid claims, and services outside the base agreement. Do not assume any of these charges apply; have the provider state what does and does not apply.
A low headline rate is difficult to compare with another offer until both proposals describe the same scope and calculation.
3. What happens to our existing billing work during the change?
Ask what the new company needs from your agency and current biller, who coordinates the handoff, and when each party's responsibility begins and ends. Ask specifically who follows claims already submitted and who keeps the record of work still open.
Have your staff review the proposed handoff alongside any existing agreement. Do not assume that hiring a new company ends your current contract or moves every outstanding item automatically.
4. What will we see when a claim needs attention?
Request an example report with fictional information or a demonstration without patient details. Can your team see what needs action, who owns it, and what happens next? Ask how an unresolved question reaches the person who can answer it.
A useful report distinguishes a claim being received from a payer deciding what to pay. CMS treats claim acknowledgments and payment advice as separate transactions (CMS Claims Processing Manual, chapter 24). A payment forecast should also be clearly identified as an estimate. Ask the company to explain its labels before relying on a dashboard total.
5. What remains our agency's responsibility?
Ask the billing company to describe the information and approvals it needs from your team. Ask which clinical and documentation responsibilities remain with your agency, and put those responsibilities in writing. Agree on who answers billing questions and how those requests will reach them.
Establish an appropriate business associate agreement where applicable and a secure process before sharing patient information (HHS business associate guidance). Do not put patient records into a public website form or ordinary email to request a quote.
6. Do you specialize in Medicare home health?
Home health billing is not general medical billing. Ask how the company handles the rules that shape every claim:
- Payment is made for each 30-day period of care under the Patient-Driven Groupings Model (PDGM), not per visit.
- A notice of admission must be accepted within 5 calendar days after the start of care. A late one reduces payment by one thirtieth for each day until it is accepted (42 CFR 484.205).
- The OASIS assessment must be accepted in Medicare's system before the claim arrives, or the claim is returned (Claims Processing Manual, chapter 10).
- A period with too few visits is paid per visit under the low-utilization payment adjustment (LUPA) instead of the full 30-day amount.
Ask how long the company has billed Original Medicare home health, and how many of its clients are home health agencies. Our Medicare home health billing guide explains each rule.
7. What do you check before each claim goes out?
Most avoidable delays start before submission. Ask which checks run on every claim, and who acts on a failed check. A solid list includes:
- Eligibility, including whether the patient has joined a Medicare Advantage plan, which changes the payer.
- Whether another agency already serves the patient for the same admission period.
- Whether the ordering or certifying practitioner is enrolled in Medicare and matches by name and National Provider Identifier.
- Whether the assessment was accepted and matches the claim.
- Whether every date falls inside the 30-day period.
Our guide on why home health claims get returned shows what each missed check looks like on the claim.
8. How do you handle returned claims, denials, appeals and medical review?
A returned claim, a rejected claim and a denial need different next steps and have different deadlines. Ask the company to explain the difference and show who handles each one. For denials, ask who calendars the 120-day deadline to request a redetermination (42 CFR 405.942).
Also ask about medical review. Medicare contractors can send an additional documentation request (ADR) and ask your agency for records. Ask who gathers the records, who tracks the response deadline, and who reads the result. Contractors also run education-based review programs such as Targeted Probe and Educate.
If your agency is in California, ask specifically about the Review Choice Demonstration. CMS has announced that it will expand the home health Review Choice Demonstration to California for billing periods beginning on or after January 18, 2027. The announcement says the demonstration covers California agencies that bill the Medicare contractor for Jurisdiction 6, and that agencies will choose between pre-claim review and postpayment review; agencies that do not choose default to postpayment review. CMS requested expedited approval of the paperwork for the expansion on October 30, 2026, so the start is subject to that approval. See the Federal Register notice, the contractor's announcement and the CMS demonstration page. Ask any company you are considering how it would support your agency through either choice.
9. Will you work inside the software we already use?
Ask whether the company works inside your current electronic medical record system or asks you to move to another one. Moving systems costs staff time and can disrupt documentation. Ask who pays for any change and what access the company needs. If it needs logins, ask how they are issued, who can see them, and how access is removed when the contract ends.
10. What are the contract term, the notice to end it, and what happens to our records if we leave?
Ask for the contract length, any auto-renewal, and how much notice you must give to end it. Ask whether you will receive your claim history, payment records and open-item lists in a usable file when the relationship ends, and how quickly. Then ask for references from current home health agencies, and call them. Ask each reference how fast questions get answered and how problems were handled.
Red flags
- A promise of guaranteed payment or zero denials. Medicare decides what it pays and when.
- A fee charged on amounts never collected, without saying so up front.
- No signed business associate agreement before the company sees patient data.
- A request for patient information by regular email or a web form.
- No clear answer on how the company tracks the 5-day notice-of-admission window.
- No named owner for follow-up when a claim is returned or denied.
In-house biller or billing company?
An in-house biller knows your patients and sits down the hall. The costs are salary, benefits, training, and the risk that one absence stops billing. Rules also change, and one person has to keep up with all of them.
A billing company spreads that work across a team and can cover absences, but it works at a distance and needs prompt answers from your staff. Some agencies keep a part-time in-house contact and hand the rest to a company. Whichever route you take, the agency still owns clinical documentation and signed orders.
Comparison checklist
Print this table and write each company's answer in its column.
| Question | Company A | Company B |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Taking over billing or selling a tool? | ||
| 2. How is the fee calculated, and when is it due? | ||
| 3. What happens to existing work during the change? | ||
| 4. What do we see when a claim needs attention? | ||
| 5. What stays our responsibility? | ||
| 6. Do you specialize in Medicare home health? | ||
| 7. What do you check before each claim goes out? | ||
| 8. How are returns, denials, appeals and reviews handled? | ||
| 9. Will you work inside our current software? | ||
| 10. Contract term, notice, and our records if we leave? |
How LMNS answers these questions
We would rather you check us against the same list. Here is where we stand, in plain terms:
- Checks: LMNS checks every claim before it goes out.
- Your software: we work inside the system you already use.
- Privacy: we sign a HIPAA business associate agreement with every agency before we see any patient data.
- Reporting: we track payments and provide a forecast based on claims Medicare has processed. It is an estimate, and payer decisions and timing can change what arrives and when.
- Guarantees: none. Medicare decides what it pays.
Ask us the other questions too: contact LMNS.
Bring the answers to one conversation
Invite the owner or administrator and the person who currently handles billing. Compare the written answers, identify any responsibility that has no owner, and resolve that gap before making a decision.
Related guides
See Medicare home health billing for how periods, certification and deadlines work, and why home health claims come back for the difference between returned, rejected and denied claims. For what the service covers, see home health billing services. To weigh an outside company against in-house billing, see outsourced home health billing.